Hatem Ben Arfa - you will be missed
Just when you think Newcastle United have a world class player on their hands who can turn a game like the flick of a switch - Hatem Ben Arfa's presence in a black and white shirt is snatched away from us with a needless tackle.
We all like players to get stuck in and be committed, but regardless of a few people who seem happy to play down what could be deemed ABH on HBA, the tackle from De Jong resulted in the player being branded ÃÅœa criminal' by Dutch journalist Hugo Borst.
Indeed, if somebody done that to you in the street, you'd have to wonder what would happen.
Players should not be judged on previous in games but De Jong's record is hardly good, the World Cup final resulted in a chest high tackle on Xabi Alonso for which he only received a yellow card from Howard Webb (and Webb wonders why he was booed).
But the HBA tackle didn't even merit a free-kick in the eyes of Martin Atkinson!
Hearing the crack of Ben Arfa's leg break on Match of the Day 2 haunted me last night.
But you can only wish him a speedy recovery now.
He'll get the best treatment and can perhaps take inspiration from Alan Smith, who in his Manchester United days was badly hurt at Anfield in 2006, while Aaron Ramsey, Antonio Valencia and former Arsenal star Eduardo have all suffered the same fate.
Hopefully Hatem will be back in action in a Toon shirt by March.
Until then it's a long road back.
LEAVE YOUR GET WELL MESSAGES HERE FOR HATEM AND WE'LL PASS THEM ON
Older/Newer
« Blog on the Tyne at the Manchester City match | Hot reception for Zoggy could re-ignite the season »






Already an adopted Geordie and cult legend in the black & white, such a shame to see him injured.
Even had the decency to wave at us travelling fans as he left the pitch, quite a feat as he was clearly in some considerable pain.
Get well soon Ben Arfa lad, we're gonna miss your brilliance and game changing ability. I hope you have a speedy recovery and that we get you on a permanent deal as soon as you're back and fully recovered!
When ben arfa was stretchered i couldn't help but feel that his wave was a goodbye a tear came to my eye realising this could be last we see of him hopefully he'll be back playing when he's fit and signs for the TOON!
Horror tackle and (at risk of sounding like Wenger) something needs to be done to give players more protection.
Wish Hatem a speedy recovery, and hopefully he's seen enough here in his short time to stick around another couple of years!! :)
It absolutely saddened me yesterday to see Hatem in that amount of pain and to see a player that the Toon Army already love, have to be stretchered off the pitch.
You could clearly hear the snap on the TV as well.
Hatem is a player that I couldnâÂÂt wait to see play a full season in Black + White, he is clearly a player that needs support of the fans and manager and will excel, something he wasnâÂÂt given the chance to do at Marseille.
Now with us, some dirty, disgusting player does this and now he might not get the chance to do it here, but I hope he does!
But I think I speak on behalf of most Newcastle fans when I sayâÂÅ
I hope you make a very speedy recovery and hope you come back the same player we all know you are.
I also hope you get a permanent deal with us, and stay for many years to come.
You are loved on Tyneside Hatem.
I think he needs to sit down with Smith and have a chat. He's been through all this, the pain of missing so much football and having to change his game.
I do hope he comes back from this okay, he's clearly someone who enjoys his football and it would be a shame for that to be taken away from his due to one man's flash of stupidity.
Best of luck on your recovery Hatem, take it easy and keep your chin up. Hopefully we'll see you back in black and white sometime.
Tous les meilleurs Hatem.
Look forward to seeing you again soon in a Toon shirt!
prendre soin!
All the best Hatem - Keep your chin up lad - we'll be waiting for you when you get back.
Hatem is a Geordie!!
Best wishes to Hatem for a speedy recovery!
Bonne chances mes ami!!!!!
Hope you come back an even better player!
Best wishes to Hatem, and hereâÂÂs hoping that he gets back soon, wishing him a speedy recovery from all the way down in Dorset.
A great player with silky smooth skills. He didn't deserve to have that kind of career ending tackle made on him by DeJong.
What's the point in having refs if they allow that kind of thing without taking any action?
I hope he'll make a full and speedy recovery and we'll see him playing in a B&W shirt again.
Fingers crossed.
Best of luck Hatem.
Get well soon.
All the Best Hatem. Get well soon. We want to see you back in a Black n White shirt.
Wishing him all the best. I hope he knows the whole of the Toon army is praying for his quick recovery. If anything good can possible come out of this terrible situation, hopefully the rest of the team will rally around him and produce a strengthened resolve and spirit in the dressing room. Get well soon, Hatem!
Hatem, all the best. So sorry to hear about your injury.
Get well soon; we'll be cheering you from the stands in no time!
Best wishes
Alex
All the best Hatem hope you make a speedy recovery! You will be back playing infront of the adoring Toon fans in no time. You will wear black and white again.
Keep your chin up Hatem because you'll be back soon playing in the black and white of Newcastle United with the crowd roaring you on.
52,000 Geordies know you're special and can't wait to see you play again.
All the best and I hope for a good recovery.
All the best to Hatem, hope to see him in a Toon shirt again. I can appreciate the lure of rehab in Southern France, as long as he comes back!
Hopefully you'll be back playing football before you know it! Preferably in B&W! However all the best in getting well soon! You'll always be welcome to play in a Toon shirt again.
All the best lad.
Get well soon Hatem.
You have made a massive impact to newcastle in such a short time. I want you to know that the entire geordie nation wishes you a speedy recovery and can't wait to see you back in action. You are already a legend to the toon army
Regards Richard
An unbelievable player, and an unbelievable career tradegy. We all wish you a speedy return Ben Arfa and I hope we can look forward to seeing you in the Black and White shirt for years to come. You are indeed The French Prodigy. The Next David Ginola. Get well soon buddy!
Get better Hatem!
We will miss you. Hope you get better soon and showcase us the skills and performances you started to show us. We feel for you and can only hope a speedy and painless as possible recovery.
Keep your head up Hatem!
We hope for many years of you playing for Newcastle United.
Hatem get well soon! Your our best player, can change a game so easily . . . just like against everton! Really hope you stay here for many years do come! ASHLEY PLEASE SPEND THE MONEY TO KEEP HIM HERE!!
Hatem, may you have a complete recovery as soon as possible. The Toon Army feels privileged to have a player of your qualities and your heart in our ranks, and we are behind you all the way! Your reaction to our supporters after getting injured is admirable and will never be forgotten. I hope your spirits remain high throughout your recovery, encouraged by the support of Newcastle fans from all over the world. I can't wait to see you back in action again, not just later this season but beyond that as well!
Get well soon Hatem!
Every Newcastle fan would love to see you make many more appearances in the black and white stripes!
All the best :-)
Get well soon. Gutted for you a top player and i hope to see you play for us again but the main thing is that you get better now.
Surely it is time to put and to all the 'tough-tackling midfield enforcer' hype that mars the British game. Apart from 'absolutely', 'tough' is the most over-used word of the 21st century.
Have a good luck at the full video, from the time of the tackle to Ben Arfa disappearing down the tunnel, and then decide who is the 'toughest', Ben Arfa or De Jong?
Bon chance pour un plein retablissement a Hatem.
Sorry, need to proof read better instead of concentrating on getting the captcha text right.
The above message should read, of course, Surely it is time to put an end to ... etc
Hatem...
In the your first few games for Newcastle, I think all Toon fans would agree you have been simply outstanding for us. Your willingness to take players on and your instinct for goal has boosted us and you will be sadly missed throughout your injury. At times in the future it will be a struggle, any recovery from a serious injury is, but it is imperative that you keep your chin up and battle on so you come back an even better player than you are now.
Good luck and howay the lads
Shaun Butler
hello I'm french but i speak a little english
I am very happy that in england you have a good thinking to ben arfa because in france anyone talk about what is happened
i'm thinking that he will be more stronger when he come back
i hope that you understanding what i said because my english isn't the best in the world good luck hatem....
Pleased your operation went well Hatem. It's not only the geordie nation that has spoken out about that dirty dutch thug even his fellow country men have turned on him and have dropped him from the national squad. It's not the best punishment for that thug but at least you have had a bit of justice. I hope you make a full recovery and you stay on Tyneside for many more years. Get well soon mate
Hatem, get well soon mate.
You might have been here for a short time but your dedication to play for us and the time spend on the pitch, plus your goal against everton, has already made you a favourite.
We will still be here for you to get back! The whole of Newcastle cant wait to see you back in the black and white!
Dear Hatem,
Distraught about the injury. The bravery and decency you displayed in applauding the fans coming off the pitch was a touching gesture unlike the disgrace of a human being who was the perpetrator.
Chin up, get back to us soon and take the PL by storm like we know you're going to! And we will hope that there will be many more seasons of you at St James Park. You'll always be at home in Newcastle!
Bonne chance!
Get well soon Hatem.
Best Wishes.
Hatem,
In the short space of time you have been here you have shown us nothing but dedication, skill and professionalism. We now want to pay you back by sticking with you through this nasty and shocking injury.
De Jong is an absolute thug and i'm sure the tackle was with intent as he knew your talent was much greater than his.
We all love you here at Newcastle Hatem, and we hope these messages of support show this.
You have the whole of Newcastle United including all the fans from around the world behind you. So when your feeling low because of the injury, just remember, that when you come back, you will get the greatest reception from the fans inside that stadium.
Get well soon Hatem.
Harry
Great to see the Dutch Natioanl Manager take action, he is obviously known for this sort of thing, so why do the FA not know this?? The Man City manager should do the same and the FA this can not keep going on. This type of tackle where the trailing legs is trapping the players standing leg is becoming more common and needs to be looked at asap! If this was one of ManU's star players there would be an enquirey..!
And as for the ref, I hope we don't see him for a while either De Gonk should have been off, the ref knows it and that why I believe he did even get a card - he totally bottled it!! -"well out of his depth" is an understatment: what a joke!
Gutted about the injury, Hatem :(
Hopefully you'll be back soon and back as the best player in the Premiership
Hatem is a Geordie
Hatem,
I'm gutted that you didn't even have a chance to score your first goal at St James' Park before a mercenary thug went out of his way to break your leg. I hope that you're back playing soon and have the home crowd screaming at you to play the type of football that you came here to produce.
Remember when youâÂÂre down over this, youâÂÂre a bigger man than the scumbag who took you out of the game because he was scared of the damage that your skills could do to his team.
YouâÂÂve only played in 3 games so far but the fans have taken to you in a big way. You battled to get a move here and you can battle through this, weâÂÂll give you any backing that we can and believe me, De Jong will not know whatâÂÂs hit him when he plays up here and has St James Park on his back. The crowd will eat him alive and heâÂÂll never forget what heâÂÂs done, nobody goes out of his way to injure one of ours and weâÂÂll not let him forget what heâÂÂs done.
I hope that the pain goes soon as I know youâÂÂll have a few sleepless nights. DonâÂÂt sit about in a room while you are recuperating. Get out and about and see what the North East has to offer and get back soon, weâÂÂre all in this together, even if we are not going through the same pain. You can take it from me that weâÂÂre all suffering in some way and weâÂÂll all get through this together and weâÂÂll see you terrorising the opposition before you know it.
You don't realise it son but that wave to the fans as you left the field on the stretcher has put you in a cult hero category with us fans. I truly hope you stay and are not tempted away by the so called big clubs. When the Geordies take you to their hearts you have truly found friends for life.
Get well soon
Get well soon Hatem
You may not have been here long, but even in that time, your outstanding performances and moments of brilliance have already made you a firm favourite among the Toon Army. Hopefully you'll be back and playing in black and white again before long - but the most important thing right now is your recovery
Good luck
Hatem, votre but contre Everton etait si manifique que j'etait sur qu'on avait un vrai prodige dans notre equipe. Et malgre votre blessure, je sais que vous allez recuperer parfaitement et nous demonstrer en plus votre majique. Je vous souhaite un bonne periode de recuperation!
Geordie Seychellois
hope ur back soon ben afra. your one of the best players i have ever seen in a black n white shirt. good luck n hope 2 c u back in action soon. ben arfa king of the toon. ;-)
All the best on your recovery Hatem, hope it is speedy and full. Love to see you run out in black and white to a stadium full of geordies cheering you on again.
Hope you recover soon mate. We really need a world-class player like you.
All the best.
Hi Ben Arfa! I am from Singapore and a big time supporter of you and Newcastle:) Hope you get well real soon and kick some ass on the pitch! Can't wait to see you back=D
Only played 3 games however you had the fans on the edge of their seats when you had the ball. Ive never seen anyone move so fast with the ball at their feet.Have a quick and successful recovery.I really hope I see you in a newcastle shirt again.
Your brilliance is already being missed on tyneside and you've only been here 1 month (that's some impression you have made).
i hope you get well soon keep your chin up we are all wishing you a speedy recover ( cos we want to see some more of that brilliant footwork you've got )
HWTL
Get well soon Hatem Ben Arfa. xx
You have lit up our club in just a few games for Newcastle and the geordie fans love you, many were heartbroken to see you injured in such a cruel way by the thug De Jong.
Hope you will be back in the black and white and have a long career at Newcastle United.
You are a fantastic player and I hope you make a full and swift recovery.
Stay strong Benny Boy the fans are awaiting your return!!
It will be a cracking day when we see those swift feet on the St James turf again!
Dear Hatem Ben Arfa,
I'am NUFC and France supporter from Malaysia, i would like to wish you for your speed recovery, i glade you choose NUFC for your new football club and i very impressed and shock with the way you thanks to us with wonderful and brilliant game.
Hope you can make speed recovery, GOD BLESS YOU, can't wait to see you play.
Hatem.
Wish you a speedy recovery
You have made a massive impact at SJP and your skills and first touch are something we haven't seen since Ginola or Robert!
I am absolutely gutted that this injury will potentially put you out for most of the season but please please please try and stay here to really show us what youre made of.
A truly great player injured by a stupid tackle from 'Kung Fu' De Jong.
R
Hatem,
Comme tout supporter de Newcastle, j'espÃÅ¡re que ton rétablissement sera rapide et complÃÅ¡te.
Tu es parti àla conquête de la Premier League - en un petit mois, tu as subjugué non seulement ton public àNewcastle, mais tous ceux et celles en Angleterre qui aiment le beau jeu. Chez tes adversaires, tu as inspiré une telle peur que le club le plus riche du monde ne voit d'autre solution que de mettre sur ton chemin un animal comme De Jong. Mais pendant que lui se fait jeter comme un malpropre par ses compatriotes, comme il le mérite, tes gestes dignes et courageux envers tes supporters en quittant la pelouse ont montré au monde entier le gouffre entre ta classe et la stupidité brutale de ton adversaire.
Tu es en voie de devenir une légende àSt James' Park, et tu peux déjàcompter sur 52000 amis dans "ton" stade, et sur beaucoup d'autres ailleurs. Imagine donc, dans les moments difficiles pendant ton rétablissement, la réception qui t'attend quand tu enfileras ànouveau le maillot noir et blanc àSJP! Là, Hatem, tu vas découvrir pour de vrai ce que veut dire l'amour et l'amitié profonde des meilleurs supporters sur cette terre! Je te connaissais bien depuis tes débuts àLyon, et je savais donc le bonheur qui nous attendait àSJP - je te remercie du fond de mon coeur d'avoir choisi Newcastle pour montrer ton immense talent àun public qui partage tes valeurs - tu as fait le bon choix et tu es vraiment un des nÃÅœtres! Patrick
already my favourite newcastle player hope to see you back to health first and formost hope its not the last we see you in the black and white stripes your a legend all the best benny we love you .
To Hatem Ben Arfa
I all simplicity. I was utterly devastated to see you injured last sunday. In your short time with our beloved team you have showed such true class and spark that I haven't seen in our team for years. I hope that you find comforting words from certain teammates that have suffered similar injuries..
Know that my thoughts are with you and I am looking forward to next year when I see you terrorizing the defences of other premier league teams again!
Howay Hatem!
Yours, Olli
Thank you Hatem for giving us excitement and hope.We love your skills.Get well soon and you know we cant wait for you to recover.In the meantime introduce yourself to Ham and pease pudding stotties....not too many mind.
Thank you Hatem for giving us excitement and hope.We love your skills.Get well soon and you know we cant wait for you to recover.In the meantime introduce yourself to Ham and pease pudding stotties....not too many mind.
already a cult hero ... got ur name on my back and ill wear it with pride! ...get well soon hatem!
It seems to me that some of these brutes are so clever at crocking someone, and making it look like an innocent tackle. It is almost an artform. This Dejong/ Ben Arfa affair has become like the elephant in the room, of course the FA know what really happened....they aren't that stupid..........are they? They'd just rather ignore it and hope it goes away. Until the next time. What would happen do you think if the FA actually had the gonnads to do something about it. Something like, make the offending player and/or his club cough up for the injured players wages and monetary recompense to the victims club. Bet that would clean the game up in a hurry.
Perhaps it's time to consider Professional Referee's, make 'em accountable. Sack them if they don't perform to an acceptable standard.
Simply put, players whose actions result in a serious injury to another player should serve a ban of equal length to the time of recovery and rehabilation of the injured player.
So yes, if you recklessly injury a player and he's out for 5 months then so are you. If you mistime a tackle, go over the top of the ball and unfortunately break the guy's leg, then you unfortunately have to be out too.
That team is down a player for a considerable time and so is yours. It would make players at least think twice before taking someone out.
why have the chronicle been so quiet on this when we have so many unanswered questions about the FA's handling of this we have video & photographic evidence that a serial thug has got away with these cowardly attack on players, and to add insult to injury the FA are telling complainants that they are powerless to act as fifa don't like it. this is of course blatant lies as they have it covered in their own rules. i brand the FA as liars and cowards, Atkinson a coward & a cheat, & nigel de jong a thug & also a shameless coward too.
suggested new entry in the dictionary
a MartinAtkinson
someone or something that's able to see what they want to. & believe what he does not see.
a blind man a man sponsored to bring forth results,
a cheat a man that brings forth result's that are not happening
a man who's mind in on a different planet
a coward that cant admit he's wrong
someone that can't be trusted
someone known to fix
the man who took over from jimmy Savill
someone caught with fingers in the till
a thief
a parasite
something that get under your skin
Get well soon Hatem,
The Black & white shirt will be awaiting your return x
Thinking of you, Hatem, and hoping your return to Black and White will be swift and smooth.
Howayyy the Lads!